573. The Novice Composer

"What kind of music have you composed? The lyrics depict a sad mood. But your music is set for a joyous mood!" said Kanniappan, the Director of the film.

"I will compose another tune, sir!" said Nathan, apologetically. It was the first opportunity he got to compose music for a film and it was the first song he composed for the film.

"I can't wait till you compose another tune. I have to shoot the scene" Kanniappan yelled at him.

He then turned to Venu, the producer of the film and told him, "I can't work with him. Replace him with Sundar."

Venu bent his head towards Kanniappan and spoke to him in a low voice, "Mr. Kanniappan. This boy is young and inexperienced. But he has talent. This being his first song, he has composed a good tune to impress us, failing to notice that the tune was not appropriate for the mood of the song. He says he will compose another tune. Let us give him a chance."

"Sir! If you think that he is so important to you, then you may engage another director in my place" said Kanniappan nonchalantly. He said "pack up" to the team and left the studio.

Venu looked at Nathan, who was standing unnerved, and told him, "Don't worry, young man. Kanniappan being a veteran director, would only talk that way. I will talk to him later and pacify him. Compose another tune for this song and keep it ready. In case, he is adamant about replacing you, I will give you a chance in my next film. You have talent. I have no doubt that you will come up in this field. Even if I have to replace you with another composer for this film, I won't ask you to return the advance payment I gave you. My best wishes" said Venu.

Nathan paid obeisance to Venu with folded hands and left.

"What is this, sir? This director speaks to you in a disrespectful way" said Venu's assistant Sakthivel.

"Success has gone to his head. He is is in demand and so he thinks he can dictate to others. He is driven by arrogance. When he doesn't give the respect due to me as the producer of the film, how can we expect him to show some consideration towards a novice like Nathan? The poor boy is rattled by Kanniappan's tantrums. Kanniappan says that the music composed by Nathan does not fit with the mood of the song. But he doesn't realize that acting towards other people without empathy and compassion doesn't fit with human nature!" said Venu, in a regretful tone.

Thirukkural
Section 2
Materialism
Chapter 58
Compassion

Verse 573 (in Tamil):

paN ennAm pAdaRku iyaibu inREl kaN ennAm
kaNNOttam illAdha kaN.

Meaning:

What value does a tune have, if it is not appropriate to the tune?

What is the purpose of having eyes that have no compassion?

(This is the English version of the Tamil story 'pudhiya isai amaippALar' by the same author.)

Verse 574 (Soon)
Verse 572